Kickstart This! #232: The Whatnot Cabinet

Designers:  Eduardo Baraf (Herbaceous, Skulk Hollow, Sunset Over Water), Steve Finn (Biblios, Herbaceous, Sunset Over Water), Keith Matejka (Herbaceous, Roll Player, Skulk Hollow)

Artists: Kim Robinson, Beth Sobel (Arboretum, Between Two Cities, Herbaceous, Lanterns: The Harvest Festival, Snow Tails, Viticulture, Viticulture Essential Edition, Wingspan, World’s Fair 1893)

Publisher:  Pencil First Games (Herbaceous, Skulk Hollow, Sunset Over Water)

Genre/Mechanisms:  set collection, tile placement

Funding Status: At the time of this posting, The Whatnot Cabinet is already fully-funded. Pledges currently total more than 2x the initial funding goal with 5 days left to go on the campaign.

Player Count: 1-4

Solo Mode:  yes

Complexity: light

Risk:  medium-low

What It’s About: “Everyone enjoys discovering small, precious objects along beaches, trails, and in the wilderness, but a special few have the knack for assembling them into a true collection. Leave your house, uncover unusual objects, and create your wonderful collection of curiosities.”

How It Works:  The Whatnot Cabinet is a fairly simple tile selection and set collection game played over 6 rounds in a 3-4 player game, and 3 rounds in a 2-player game.

At the start of the game, 5 of the 8 Curiosity Cards are placed out; whoever fulfills each Card’s requirements first over the course of the game claims the associated tile for end game-scoring. Players also place out 1 of the game’s 5 Wonder Cards; each tile in a player’s collection matching the depicted item will earn the player 1 additional point at the end of the game.

Then, each round, players reveal 4 Curio Tiles to make up the tile market known as “The Outdoors.” Players take their turn in turn order, choosing an action that allows them to draw some combination of tiles from the bag or choose them from the market, before finally placing their 2 selected tiles in their “Whatnot Cabinet.” Choosing a more powerful action with more options will put the player later in the turn order for the subsequent round.

Players score points as they complete rows and columns. Rows are object-themed– collecting 3 of the same object will earn the player a 3 Point Token, and collecting 3 different objects will earn the player a 1 Point Token. A mishmash of a row, where some of the objects are the same and some are different, will earn the player a Blank Token worth 0 points. The same goes for columns, which are color-themed. Having all 4 objects of the same color in a column will earn the player a 4 Point Token, and all differently-colored objects will earn them a 2 Point Token. A combination of the two again results in a Blank Token worth 0 points.

At the end of 6 rounds (or 3 in a 2-player game), players add up their scoring tokens for columns and rows, along with any Curiosity Cards they collected over the course of the game, a point per Special Tile, 1 points for each tile object matching the one on the Wonder Card, 1 point for every Crown icon on their Tiles, and points for finishing in one of the first 3 spaces on the turn order track. The player with the most total points wins, with ties broken by the player with the most Blank Tokens, and then by the player who finished highest on the turn order track.

Comparisons:  The Azul games, particularly the first one, are prime examples of simple games where players score points for collecting and ordering tiles in a specific way on their player boards. Barenpark and Quadropolis are two more lighter tile placement & set collection games. Artist Beth Sobel has also worked on Arboretum, Between Two Cities, and Lanterns, three more light tile-placement games. And Kingdomino and Patchwork are yet two more lighter tile placement games.

What Should I Pledge?:
$39 The Whatnot Cabinet: includes a copy of the game and the Fascination Pack Mini-Expansion.
$78 The Whatnot Cabinet & Sprouts Combo: everything in The Whatnot Cabinet pledge level, plus a copy of Herbaceous Sprouts with the Green Thumb Mini-Expansion.
$120 Pencil First Collectors Bundle: everything in The Whatnot Cabinet & Sprouts Combo, plus Sunset Over Water with the Nature’s Muse Mini-Expansion and Herbaceous with the Flavor Pack Mini-Expansion.


KS Exclusives

All-In Total: If you’re only purchasing The Whatnot Cabinet, then in the continental U.S., you’re looking at $39 for The Whatnot Cabinet pledge plus $8 in shipping for a total of $47. If you’re getting the Pencil First Collector’s Bundle, then you’re looking at $120 for the pledge and $20 in shipping for a total of $140.

The Whatnot Cabinet completes its Kickstarter on Monday, June 22nd and tentatively ships in May 2021.

Leave comment